TasteToronto | The Best Pumpkin Pie in Toronto

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website.

View our Privacy Policy

Guides / Spots

The Best Pumpkin Pie in Toronto

The Best Pumpkin Pie in Toronto

The Best Pumpkin Pie in Toronto

It's that time of year again, people. The holiday season is upon us.

Easily the best food holiday of the year, dinner tables will soon be filled with an all-star lineup of items. From the Thanksgiving turkey that your dad insists on carving to the cranberry sauce that comes straight from the can and the gravy that only your grandma knows the recipe to, it's happy eating during Thanksgiving.

Every feast isn't complete without pumpkin pie, the iconic Thanksgiving dessert that appears once a year but is arguably the star of the show. From beautiful pies to vegan and gluten-free options, traditional pies to pumpkin dulce de leche meringue pies, you'll be the star of the show walking in with any offerings from this list.

244 Augusta Ave

Bunner's Bakeshop

Bunner's Bakeshop

Making their home in Kensington Market, Bunner's Bake Shop stakes their claim as Toronto's number one vegan and gluten-free bakeshop. Open since 2010; they promise you won't tell the difference between their baked offerings and those made with traditional ingredients. The pumpkin pie is classic and safe to eat for everyone at the dinner table.

927 The Queensway

The Pie Commission

The Pie Commission

The Pie Commission, founded by two high school buddies, made their name in Toronto through their love of bringing meat pies to a city that didn't have them. They've since expanded their pie game and offer a Thanksgiving pie that comes fully baked and frozen. Thaw it out on the counter and you're good for the party.

1121 Queen St E

Bobbette & Belle

Bobbette & Belle

If you're looking for something that's a bit more tart and a bit less deep-dish pie, Bobbette and Belle have their beautiful pumpkin made in a torte style. Buttery crust and homemade filling are the stars of the show, with a delicate balance of spices, pumpkin puree, sour cream and condensed milk rounding out a smooth, luxurious texture.

55 Glen Cameron Rd Unit #9

Manal Bashir Pastry Co.

Manal Bashir Pastry Co.

Probably the most beautiful pumpkin pie on this list, Manal Bashir Pastry Co. takes pride in creating artfully hand-crafted cakes and pastries that are simple in design but rooted in fostering memories and experiences that last a lifetime. Their maple pumpkin tart is made of spiced pumpkin tart, maple chantilly cream and oat crumble.

326 Harbord St

My Sweetie Pie

My Sweetie Pie

Located in the heart of Harbord Village and across from Bickford Park, My Sweetie Pie services their community specialty baked goods and hand-crafted artisanal pies. Decadent, delicious and in stock for a limited time, their pumpkin pie will be perfect on the centre of your Thanksgiving table.

100 Harbord St

Almond Butterfly - Harbord Village

Almond Butterfly - Harbord Village

For the University of Toronto students spending their Thanksgiving with friends this year, Almond Butterfly has one of their two locations on Harbord Street, which is right on the outskirts of campus. They offer a classic pumpkin pie that is dairy and gluten-free, so you can satisfy your pumpkin pie cravings while keeping everyone happy.

120 Dundas St W

Butter Baker

Butter Baker

For those that are spending their Thanksgiving right in the heart of downtown Butter Baker will satisfy your pumpkin pie needs. Their holiday special pumpkin pie is made with fresh pumpkin custard with caramel and mixed spices, filled in a flaky pie crust, finished with torched meringue and handcrafted marzipan pumpkins. It looks just as good as it tastes.

New Pie Co.

New Pie Co.

New Pie Co. presents a revolutionary new concept because they are an entirely online store without an official brick-and-mortar location. Their new Cookie Butter Pumpkin pie will be the star of your Thanksgiving, with hand-rolled butter crust, spiced pumpkin and cookie butter filling, candied pecans and cookie butter caramel. New Pie Co. offers pick up twice a week (check the website), and they've launched delivery right in time for Thanksgiving. You're in luck.

The Best Pumpkin Pie in Toronto

Guides / Spots

21 days ago

The Best Pumpkin Pie in Toronto

Kevin Gallardo

Kevin Gallardo

Instagram

It's that time of year again, people. The holiday season is upon us.

Easily the best food holiday of the year, dinner tables will soon be filled with an all-star lineup of items. From the Thanksgiving turkey that your dad insists on carving to the cranberry sauce that comes straight from the can and the gravy that only your grandma knows the recipe to, it's happy eating during Thanksgiving.

Every feast isn't complete without pumpkin pie, the iconic Thanksgiving dessert that appears once a year but is arguably the star of the show. From beautiful pies to vegan and gluten-free options, traditional pies to pumpkin dulce de leche meringue pies, you'll be the star of the show walking in with any offerings from this list.

244 Augusta Ave

Bunner's Bakeshop

Bunner's Bakeshop

Making their home in Kensington Market, Bunner's Bake Shop stakes their claim as Toronto's number one vegan and gluten-free bakeshop. Open since 2010; they promise you won't tell the difference between their baked offerings and those made with traditional ingredients. The pumpkin pie is classic and safe to eat for everyone at the dinner table.

1121 Queen St E

Bobbette & Belle

Bobbette & Belle

If you're looking for something that's a bit more tart and a bit less deep-dish pie, Bobbette and Belle have their beautiful pumpkin made in a torte style. Buttery crust and homemade filling are the stars of the show, with a delicate balance of spices, pumpkin puree, sour cream and condensed milk rounding out a smooth, luxurious texture.

120 Dundas St W

Butter Baker

Butter Baker

For those that are spending their Thanksgiving right in the heart of downtown Butter Baker will satisfy your pumpkin pie needs. Their holiday special pumpkin pie is made with fresh pumpkin custard with caramel and mixed spices, filled in a flaky pie crust, finished with torched meringue and handcrafted marzipan pumpkins. It looks just as good as it tastes.

New Pie Co.

New Pie Co.

New Pie Co. presents a revolutionary new concept because they are an entirely online store without an official brick-and-mortar location. Their new Cookie Butter Pumpkin pie will be the star of your Thanksgiving, with hand-rolled butter crust, spiced pumpkin and cookie butter filling, candied pecans and cookie butter caramel. New Pie Co. offers pick up twice a week (check the website), and they've launched delivery right in time for Thanksgiving. You're in luck.